A Left Identity Forces Equality with Unity
Advanced Ring Theory question for CSIR-NET · GATE. Choose an option, check your answer, then read the detailed solution.
Question RT-019
Let $R$ be a ring with unity $1\neq0$, not assumed commutative. Suppose $e\in R$ satisfies $e\cdot a=a$ for every $a\in R$. Which of the following must necessarily be true?
Detailed Solution
Since $1$ is the (two-sided) multiplicative identity of $R$, it satisfies $x\cdot1=x$ for every $x\in R$, in particular for $x=e$: $$ e\cdot1=e. $$ On the other hand, the hypothesis on $e$ says $e\cdot a=a$ for every $a\in R$, so taking $a=1$ gives $$ e\cdot1=1. $$ Combining these two equalities, $$ e=e\cdot1=1. $$ So $e=1$ is forced, and this argument used only the defining property $x\cdot1=x$ of the unity together with the hypothesis on $e$ — commutativity of $R$ was never needed. This rules out option B. Option C fails because if $e=0$, then $e\cdot a=0\neq a$ for any nonzero $a$ (recalling $1\neq0$ guarantees $R$ has nonzero elements), contradicting the hypothesis. Option D is also false, since the argument above works in any ring with unity, commutative or not, and does not require $R$ to be a field. Thus the correct option is $\boxed{\mathrm{A}}$.Concepts tested: Rings with unityIdentity elementsLeft identityUniqueness of unity
💬 Discuss this problem
Have a doubt or a different approach? Continue the mathematics discussion on Telegram.
Join Telegram Discussion
Have a doubt or a different approach? Continue the mathematics discussion on Telegram.
Join Telegram Discussion
Keep Practising
More Ring Theory Questions
Sum of a Unit and a Commuting Nilpotent Element
Is the sum of a unit and a commuting nilpotent element always invertible?
Attempt Question →Degree of the Product of Polynomials
Why does the degree of a product equal the sum of degrees over an integral domain?
Attempt Question →Characteristic of a Ring Satisfying $x^3=x$
What restriction does the identity $x^3=x$ impose on the characteristic of a ring?
Attempt Question →